My teacher assigned us an interesting reading and posted some comments for us to reflect on. Here you have them.
Initial commnets:
I
was struck by the part that said , that when Gulliver arrived to Lilliput
, he felt so bad like : alone and dismissed , because when he arrived to
Lilliput , the lilliputians tread him badly.
My opinion is that all the people don’t have to mistreat people that you just met,
as we see reflected in the Lilliputians to Gulliver. But Gulliver had no grudge
with the Lilliputians, and Gulliver helped them with a canoe. Even though the Lilliputians
punished Gulliver.
The conclusion is that in the life everyone feels like Gulliver, but we never
have to forget that God is always with us in any situation, and God never fails
us. Also, sometimes it is difficult for us to forgive and forget but the best
solution is to have no grudge and forgive!
Gulliver’s Travels
Discussion Questions by Oscar Víquez
Who was Jonathan Swift? What is he best
known for?
Jonathan Swift
was an Irish author and satirist. Best known for writing Gulliver's Travels, he
was dean of St. Patrick's Cathedral in Dublin.
Born on November 30, 1667, Irish
author, clergyman and satirist Jonathan Swift grew up fatherless. Under the
care of his uncle, he received a bachelor's degree from Trinity College and
then worked as a statesman's assistant.
In 1704, Swift anonymously released A
Tale of a Tub and The Battle of the Books. Tub,
although widely popular with the masses, was harshly disapproved of by the
Church of England. Ostensibly, it criticized religion, but Swift meant it as a
parody of pride. Nonetheless, his writings earned him a reputation in London,
and when the Tories came into power in 1710, they asked him to become editor of
the Examiner, their official paper. After a time,
he became fully immersed in the political landscape and began writing some of
the most cutting and well-known political pamphlets of the day, including: The Conduct of the Allies,
an attack on the Whigs. Privy to the inner circle of Tory government, Swift
laid out his private thoughts and feelings in a stream of letters to his
beloved Stella. They would later be published as The
Journal to Stella.
What literary period does he represent?
Jonathan Swift belongs to the
Enlightenment period, sometimes referred to as the Age of Reason, was a
confluence of ideas and activities that took place throughout the eighteenth
century in Western Europe, England, and the American colonies. Scientific
rationalism, exemplified by the scientific method, was the hallmark of
everything related to the Enlightenment. Following close on the heels of the
Renaissance, Enlightenment thinkers believed that the advances of science and
industry heralded a new age of egalitarianism and progress for humankind. More
goods were being produced for less money, people were traveling more, and the
chances for the upwardly mobile to actually change their station in life were
significantly improving. At the same time, many voices were expressing sharp
criticism of some time-honored cultural institutions. The Church, in
particular, was singled out as stymieing the forward march of human reason.
Define Satire.
Satire is a technique employed by writers to expose and criticize
foolishness and corruption of an individual or a society by using humor, irony,
exaggeration or ridicule. It intends to improve humanity by criticizing its
follies and foibles. A writer in a satire uses fictional characters, which
stand for real people, to expose and condemn their corruption.
A writer may point a satire toward a person, a country or even the
entire world. Usually, a satire is a comical piece of writing which makes fun
of an individual or a society to expose its stupidity and shortcomings. In
addition, he hopes that those he criticizes will improve their characters by
overcoming their weaknesses.
Why do you think Swift used this genre?
Swift himself admitted to wanting to
"vex" the world with his satire, and it is certainly in his tone,
more than anything else, that one most feels his intentions. Besides the coarse
language and bawdy scenes, probably the most important element that Dr. Bowdler
deleted from the original Gulliver's
Travels was this satiric
tone. The tone of the original varies from mild wit to outright derision, but
always present is a certain strata of ridicule.
Thomas Bowdler was an English physician and
philanthropist, best known for publishing The Family Shakspeare, and other
works from writers like Jonathan Swift an expurgated edition
of William Shakespeare's work, edited by his sister Henrietta Maria Bowdler, intended to be more appropriate for 19th
century women and children than the original. Although early editions of the
work were published with the spelling "Shakspeare", after Bowdler's
death, later editions (from 1847) adopted the spelling "Shakespeare",
reflecting changes in the standard spelling of Shakespeare's name.
What do you think Swift's view of humanity
is? Do you agree with it? Why or why not?
Swift´s perception of the world is
represented in fourth trip in his work, Gulliver returns to England before a
final journey, to the land of the Houyhnhnms, who are a superior race of
intelligent horses. But the region is also home to the Yahoos, a vile and
depraved race of ape-like creatures. Gulliver is eventually exiled from
Houyhnhnm society when the horses gently insist that Gulliver must return to live
among his own kind. After this fourth and final voyage, he returns to England,
where he has great difficulty adjusting to everyday life. All people everywhere
remind him of the Yahoos. For me Yahoos represent a satiric way of representing
the human side of hate and violence.
What do you think the controversy between
the Big-Endians and the Small-Endians represents?
The Big-Endian/Little-Endian controversy
reflects, in a much simplified form, British quarrels over religion. England
had been, less than 200 years previously, a Catholic (Big-Endian) country; but
a series of reforms beginning in the 1530s under King Henry VIII (ruled 1509–1547), Edward VI (1547–1553), and Queen Elizabeth I (1558–1603) had converted most of the country to
Protestantism (Little-Endianism), in the Episcopalian form of the Church of England. At
the same time, revolution and reform in Scotland (1560) had also converted that
country to Presbyterian Protestantism, which led to fresh difficulties when
England and Scotland were united under one ruler, James I (1603–25).
Swift was satirizing the fact that
often wars are fought over the most trivial of things (breaking eggs at the
opposite ends) and some take this to mean that he was ridiculing the wars
between England and France. However, more credence is given to the conflicts
between Catholics and Protestants, essentially they are both Christian, just
like Lilliput and Blefescu are the same race, but they have trivial differences
that are blown out of all proportion. England had previously been a Catholic
country (big-endian) but was now a Protestant country (little-endian).
In Lilliput eggs were originally
broken at the big end but then one particular Emperor decreed that eggs should
be broken at the little end. This later led to uproar and six rebellions
between the big endians and the little endians, and one Emperor was actually
killed over it. The neighbouring island of Blefescu still adhere to
Big-endianism and insist on breaking their eggs at the big end, while Lilliput
are Little- endians. They are presently at war over the matter.
What do we learn about the Lilliputians
with the knowledge that they believe no other kingdoms exist except those of
Lilliput and Blefuscu?

The idea of a perfect world calls the attention of different people. Like many narratives about voyages to nonexistent
lands, Gulliver’s Travels explores the idea of utopia—an
imaginary model of the ideal community. The idea of a utopia is an ancient one,
going back at least as far as the description in Plato’s Republic of a city-state governed by the wise
and expressed most famously in English by Thomas More’s Utopia. Swift nods to both works in his own
narrative, though his attitude toward utopia is much more skeptical, and one of
the main aspects he points out about famous historical utopias is the tendency
to privilege the collective group over the individual. The children of Plato’s Republic are raised communally, with no
knowledge of their biological parents, in the understanding that this system
enhances social fairness. Swift has the Lilliputians similarly raise their
offspring collectively, but its results are not exactly utopian, since Lilliput
is torn by conspiracies, jealousies, and backstabbing.
Why does Gulliver have such a strong
reaction against the Yahoos when he first sees them?
This idea that people living outside of Europe were somehow closer to
nature or less tainted by civilization was a common one in Swift's day. Gulliver
returns to the sea as the captain of a merchantman as he is bored with his
employment as a surgeon. On this voyage he is forced to find new additions to
his crew, whom he believes to have turned the rest of the crew against him. His
crew then mutiny, and after keeping him contained for some time resolve to
leave him on the first piece of land they come across and continue as pirates.
He is abandoned in a landing boat and comes upon a race of hideous, deformed
and savage humanoid creatures to which he conceives a violent antipathy.
Shortly afterwards he meets a race of horses who call themselves Houyhnhnms (which
in their language means "the perfection of nature"); they are the
rulers, while the deformed creatures called Yahoos are
human beings in their base form. Gulliver becomes a member of a horse's
household, and comes to both admire and emulate the Houyhnhnms and their
lifestyle, rejecting his fellow humans as merely Yahoos endowed with some
semblance of reason which they only use to exacerbate and add to the vices
Nature gave them. However, an Assembly of the Houyhnhnms rules that Gulliver, a
Yahoo with some semblance of reason, is a danger to their civilization, and
expels him. He is then rescued, against his will, by a Portuguese ship, and is
surprised to see that Captain Pedro de Mendez, a Yahoo, is a wise, courteous
and generous person. He returns to his home in England, but he is unable to
reconcile himself to living among 'Yahoos' and becomes a recluse, remaining in
his house, largely avoiding his family and his wife, and spending several hours
a day speaking with the horses in his stables; in effect becoming insane. This
book uses coarse metaphors to describe human depravity, and the Houyhnhms are symbolized
as not only perfected nature but also the emotional barrenness which Swift
maintained that devotion to reason brought.
Who are the Struldbruggs? Are they happy
to have eternal life? Why or why not?
“That which I do not fear a problem will never be”
Oscar Víquez. I tried to find a quote that might represent why they do not fear
death, since I did not find any I created my own.
Swift's work depicts the evil of immortality without eternal youth. They
are easily recognized by a red dot above their left eyebrow. They are normal
human beings until they reach the age of thirty, at which time they become
dejected. Upon reaching the age of eighty they become legally dead, and suffer
from many ailments including the loss of eyesight and the loss of hair.
What was your favorite voyage in the
story? Why?
Definitely when there is personal growth that would be
my favorite part. The second voyage is to Brobdingnag, a land of
Giants where Gulliver seems as small as the Lilliputians were to him. Gulliver is
afraid, but his keepers are surprisingly gentle. He is humiliated by the King
when he is made to see the difference between how England is and how it ought
to be. Gulliver realizes how revolting he must have seemed to the Lilliputians.